Table 2 Characteristics of comparative studies
Study | Study location | Study type | Onlay graft donor site | Defect type | Age (years) | Smokers (%) | Number of implant (patients) | Implant location | Implant success | Bone loss from grafted level | Timing of implant in DP group (months) | Post-loading follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Misch and Dietsh 1994 [16] | USA | RS | Iliac | V and H | NR | NR | SP 21 (-) DP 147 (-) | Mx Mx | NR | NR | NR | 26–97 months |
Triplett and Schow 1996 [17] | USA | RS | Iliac and cranium | V and H | NR | NR | SP 65 (NR) DP 110 (NR) | Mx and Mn Mx and Mn | 84.6 88.2 | NR | 4–8 | Minimum 1 year |
Widmark et al. 2001 [18] | Sweden | RS | Iliac | V and H | NR | NR | SP 68 (NR) DP 33 (NR) | Mx and Mn Mx and Mn | NR | NR | 3–4 | 5 years |
Peñarrocha-Diago et al. 2013 [9] | Spain | RS | Intraoral | H | Range 21–82 | 42.8 | SP 38 (20) DP 33 (22) | NR NR | 89.5a 96.9 | 0.69± 0.67 0.20± 0.50 | 5–8 | 1 year |
Tosun et al. 2017 [19] | Turkey | RS | Iliac | NR | 49.3± 11.8 | NR | SP 42 (-) DP 61 (-) | 13 Mx, 29 Mn 48 Mx, 13 Mn | NR | 1.31± 0.95 0.49± 076 | 3 | 29 ± 4.2 |